autodetection.ml 21.4 KB
Newer Older
Andrei Paskevich's avatar
Andrei Paskevich committed
1 2 3
(********************************************************************)
(*                                                                  *)
(*  The Why3 Verification Platform   /   The Why3 Development Team  *)
Andrei Paskevich's avatar
Andrei Paskevich committed
4
(*  Copyright 2010-2016   --   INRIA - CNRS - Paris-Sud University  *)
Andrei Paskevich's avatar
Andrei Paskevich committed
5 6 7 8
(*                                                                  *)
(*  This software is distributed under the terms of the GNU Lesser  *)
(*  General Public License version 2.1, with the special exception  *)
(*  on linking described in file LICENSE.                           *)
9
(*                                                                  *)
Andrei Paskevich's avatar
Andrei Paskevich committed
10
(********************************************************************)
11

12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
(*****
1) For every block, for every executable call the prover using the
version switch and add the prover to the configuration if the version
match one of the version_ok or version_old but none of the version_bad
2) We consider that an executable name which appears in a block, but
which version isn't a version_ok, version_old or version_bad has an
unknown version
3) For every executable which have an unknown version, we add the
prover using the first block that contains it.

Don't use the family argument except when you add manualy one prover.

So the order of the block is used only when the version of an
executable appears in none of the block.

A block with more than one exec fields is now the same thing than if you
split the block into blocks containing one fields.

New message field that allows to print a message when a prover is
31
detected. If a message is not present, we print ", OK." if the version
32 33 34 35 36 37
is good (version_good) and not old, and " (it is an old version)." if
the version is old (version_old).

The field command can be missing in a block, in that case the block
defines a version known to be buggy: no prover config is generated.

38 39
The regexp must start with ^.

40 41
*)

42
open Format
François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
43
open Stdlib
44
open Whyconf
45
module Wc = Whyconf
46 47
open Rc

48
let debug = Debug.register_info_flag "autodetect"
Andrei Paskevich's avatar
Andrei Paskevich committed
49 50
  ~desc:"Print@ debugging@ messages@ about@ auto-detection@ \
         of@ external@ provers."
51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58

(* auto-detection of provers *)

type prover_kind = ATP | ITP
type prover_autodetection_data =
    { kind : prover_kind;
      prover_id : string;
      prover_name : string;
59
      prover_altern : string;
60
      compile_time_support : bool;
61 62 63
      execs : string list;
      version_switch : string;
      version_regexp : string;
64 65 66
      versions_ok : Str.regexp list;
      versions_old : Str.regexp list;
      versions_bad : Str.regexp list;
67 68
      (** If none it's a fake prover (very bad version) *)
      prover_command : string option;
69
      prover_command_steps : string option;
70 71
      prover_driver : string;
      prover_editor : string;
72
      prover_in_place : bool;
73
      use_at_auto_level : int;
74
      message : string option;
75 76 77 78 79
    }

let prover_keys =
  let add acc k = Sstr.add k acc in
  List.fold_left add Sstr.empty
80 81
    ["name";"compile_time_support";
     "exec";"version_switch";"version_regexp";
82
     "version_ok";"version_old";"version_bad";"command"; "command_steps";
83
     "editor";"driver";"in_place";"message";"alternative";"use_at_auto_level"]
84 85 86

let load_prover kind (id,section) =
  check_exhaustive section prover_keys;
87
  let reg_map = List.rev_map why3_regexp_of_string in
88
  let prover = { kind = kind;
89 90
    prover_id = id;
    prover_name = get_string section "name";
91
    prover_altern = get_string section ~default:"" "alternative";
92
    compile_time_support =
93
      get_bool section ~default:false "compile_time_support";
94 95 96
    execs = get_stringl section "exec";
    version_switch = get_string section ~default:"" "version_switch";
    version_regexp = get_string section ~default:"" "version_regexp";
97 98 99
    versions_ok = reg_map (get_stringl section ~default:[] "version_ok");
    versions_old = reg_map (get_stringl section ~default:[] "version_old");
    versions_bad = reg_map (get_stringl section ~default:[] "version_bad");
100
    prover_command = get_stringo section "command";
101
    prover_command_steps = get_stringo section "command_steps";
102
    prover_driver = get_string section ~default:""  "driver";
103
    prover_editor = get_string section ~default:"" "editor";
104
    prover_in_place = get_bool section ~default:false "in_place";
105
    use_at_auto_level = get_int section ~default:0 "use_at_auto_level";
106
    message = get_stringo section "message";
107 108 109 110 111
  } in
  if prover.prover_command != None && prover.prover_driver = "" then
    invalid_arg
      (sprintf "In section prover %s command specified without driver" id);
  prover
112

113
(* dead code
114 115 116 117
let editor_keys =
  let add acc k = Sstr.add k acc in
  List.fold_left add Sstr.empty
    ["command"]
118
*)
119 120 121

let load_editor section =
  check_exhaustive section prover_keys;
MARCHE Claude's avatar
MARCHE Claude committed
122 123
  { editor_name = get_string section "name";
    editor_command = get_string section "command";
124 125 126
    editor_options = []
  }

127
(** returned in reverse order *)
128 129
let load rc =
  let atps = get_family rc "ATP" in
130
  let atps = List.rev_map (load_prover ATP) atps in
131
  let itps = get_family rc "ITP" in
132
  let tps = List.fold_left (Lists.cons (load_prover ITP)) atps itps in
133 134
  tps

135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144
let load_prover_shortcut acc (_, section) =
  let name = get_string section "name" in
  let version = get_stringo section "version" in
  let altern = get_stringo section "alternative" in
  let shortcuts = get_stringl section "shortcut" in
  let fp = mk_filter_prover ?version ?altern name in
  List.fold_left (fun acc shortcut ->
    (fp,shortcut)::acc
  ) acc shortcuts

145 146 147 148 149
module Hstr2 = Hashtbl.Make(struct
  type t = string * string
  let hash = Hashtbl.hash
  let equal = (=)
end)
François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
150

151 152
type env =
  {
153
    (* memoization of (exec_name,version_switch)
154
        -> Some output | None doesn't exists *)
François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
155
    prover_output : string option Hstr2.t;
156
    (* existing executable table:
François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
157 158
        exec_name -> | Some (priority, id, prover_config)
                                  unknown version (neither good or bad)
159
                     | None               there is a good version *)
François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
160 161
    prover_unknown_version :
      (int * string * config_prover) option Hstr.t;
162
    (* string -> priority * prover  *)
François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
163
    prover_shortcuts : (int * prover) Hstr.t;
164 165 166 167
    mutable possible_prover_shortcuts : (filter_prover * string) list;
  }

let create_env shortcuts =
François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
168 169 170
{ prover_output = Hstr2.create 10;
  prover_unknown_version = Hstr.create 10;
  prover_shortcuts = Hstr.create 5;
171 172 173
  possible_prover_shortcuts = shortcuts;
 }

François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
174 175 176 177 178 179
let next_priority =
  let r = ref 0 in
  fun () -> decr r; !r

let highest_priority = 0

180
let read_auto_detection_data main =
181 182
  let filename = Filename.concat (Whyconf.datadir main)
    "provers-detection-data.conf" in
183 184
  try
    let rc = Rc.from_file filename in
185 186 187
    let shortcuts =
      List.fold_left load_prover_shortcut [] (get_family rc "shortcut") in
    List.rev (load rc), create_env shortcuts
188 189
  with
    | Failure "lexing" ->
190
        Loc.errorm "Syntax error in provers-detection-data.conf@."
191
    | Not_found ->
192
        Loc.errorm "provers-detection-data.conf not found at %s@." filename
193

194
(* dead code
195
let provers_found = ref 0
196
*)
197

198 199 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210
let read_editors main =
  let filename = Filename.concat (Whyconf.datadir main)
    "provers-detection-data.conf" in
  try
    let rc = Rc.from_file filename in
    List.fold_left (fun editors (id, section) ->
      Meditor.add id (load_editor section) editors
    ) Meditor.empty (get_family rc "editor")
  with
    | Failure "lexing" ->
        Loc.errorm "Syntax error in provers-detection-data.conf@."
    | Not_found ->
        Loc.errorm "provers-detection-data.conf not found at %s@." filename
211

212
let make_command =
213
  let cmd_regexp = Str.regexp "%\\(.\\)" in
214 215 216 217 218 219
  fun exec com ->
    let replace s = match Str.matched_group 1 s with
      | "e" -> exec
      | c -> "%"^c
    in
    Str.global_substitute cmd_regexp replace com
220

221
(* dead code
222 223 224
let sanitize_exec =
  let first c = match c with
    | '_' | ' ' -> "_"
225
    | _ -> char_to_alpha c
226 227 228
  in
  let rest c = match c with
    | '+' | '-' | '.' -> String.make 1 c
229
    | _ -> char_to_alnumus c
230
  in
231
  sanitizer first rest
232
*)
233

234
let ask_prover_version exec_name version_switch =
235
  let out = Filename.temp_file "out" "" in
236
  let cmd = sprintf "%s %s" exec_name version_switch in
237
  let c = sprintf "(%s) >%s 2>&1" cmd out in
238
  Debug.dprintf debug "Run : %s@." c;
239 240 241 242 243 244 245 246
  try
    let ret = Sys.command c in
    let ch = open_in out in
    let c = Sysutil.channel_contents ch in
    close_in ch;
    Sys.remove out;
    if ret <> 0 then begin
      Debug.dprintf debug "command '%s' failed. Output:@\n%s@." cmd c;
247
      None
248 249 250 251
    end else Some c
  with Not_found | End_of_file | Sys_error _ ->
    Debug.dprintf debug "command '%s' failed@." cmd;
    None
252 253 254

let ask_prover_version env exec_name version_switch =
  try
François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
255
    Hstr2.find env.prover_output (exec_name,version_switch)
256 257
  with Not_found ->
    let res = ask_prover_version exec_name version_switch in
François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
258
    Hstr2.add env.prover_output (exec_name,version_switch) res;
259 260
    res

261
let check_version version schema = Str.string_match schema version 0
262 263

let known_version env exec_name =
François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
264
  Hstr.replace env.prover_unknown_version exec_name None
265

François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
266 267 268 269
let unknown_version env exec_name prover_id prover_config priority =
  if not (Hstr.mem env.prover_unknown_version exec_name)
  then Hstr.replace env.prover_unknown_version exec_name
    (Some (priority,prover_id,prover_config))
270 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 280 281 282 283 284 285 286 287 288


let empty_alt s = if s = "" then "alt" else s

let find_prover_altern provers prover_id =
  if not (Mprover.mem prover_id provers) then prover_id
  else
    let prover_id =
      {prover_id with
        Wc.prover_altern = empty_alt prover_id.Wc.prover_altern} in
    if not (Mprover.mem prover_id provers) then prover_id
    else
    let rec aux n =
      let prover_id_n = {prover_id with
        Wc.prover_altern = sprintf "%s_%i"
          (empty_alt prover_id.Wc.prover_altern) n} in
      if Mprover.mem prover_id_n provers
      then aux (n+1)
      else prover_id_n in
289 290 291
    (* start with 2 in order to have toto_alt, toto_alt2,
       toto_alt3,... and not toto_alt, toto_alt1 which can be
       confusing *)
292 293 294
    aux 2

let add_prover_with_uniq_id prover provers =
295
  (* find an unique prover triplet *)
296 297
  let prover_id = find_prover_altern provers prover.Wc.prover in
  let prover = {prover with Wc.prover = prover_id} in
298
  Mprover.add prover_id prover provers
299

300 301 302 303
let add_prover_shortcuts env prover =
  let rec aux = function
    | [] -> []
    | (fp,s)::l when filter_prover fp prover ->
François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
304
      Hstr.replace env.prover_shortcuts s (highest_priority,prover);
305 306 307 308
      aux l
    | a::l -> a::(aux l) in
  env.possible_prover_shortcuts <- aux env.possible_prover_shortcuts

François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
309
let add_id_prover_shortcut env id prover priority =
310
  match Hstr.find_opt env.prover_shortcuts id with
François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
311
  | Some (p,_) when p >= priority -> ()
312
(*
313
  | Some _ -> assert false
314
 *)
François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
315 316
  | _ -> Hstr.replace env.prover_shortcuts id (priority,prover)

317 318 319 320 321 322 323 324 325 326 327 328 329 330 331
let prover_auto_levels = Hprover.create 5

let record_prover_for_auto_mode prover level =
  Hprover.replace prover_auto_levels prover (level,false)

let check_prover_auto_level prover =
  try
    let lev,_ = Hprover.find prover_auto_levels prover in
    Hprover.replace prover_auto_levels prover (lev,true)
  with Not_found -> ()

let generate_auto_strategies config =
  eprintf "Generating strategies:@.";
  Hprover.iter
    (fun p (lev,b) ->
332 333
     if b then eprintf "  Prover %a will be used in Auto level >= %d@."
                       Whyconf.print_prover p lev) prover_auto_levels;
334 335 336 337 338 339 340 341
  (* Split *)
  let code = "t split_goal_wp exit" in
  let split = {
      strategy_name = "Split";
      strategy_desc = "Split@ the@ goal@ into@ subgoals";
      strategy_shortcut = "s";
      strategy_code = code }
  in
342 343 344 345 346 347 348 349
  (* Inline *)
  let code = "t introduce_premises next next: t inline_goal exit" in
  let inline = {
      strategy_name = "Inline";
      strategy_desc = "Inline@ definitions@ in@ the@ conclusion@ of@ the@ goal";
      strategy_shortcut = "i";
      strategy_code = code }
  in
350 351 352 353 354
  (* Auto level 1 *)
  let provers_level1 =
    Hprover.fold
      (fun p (lev,b) acc ->
       if b && lev = 1 then
355 356 357 358
         let name =
           p.Whyconf.prover_name ^ "," ^
             p.Whyconf.prover_version ^ "," ^ p.Whyconf.prover_altern
         in name :: acc
359 360 361 362 363 364 365 366 367 368 369 370 371 372 373 374 375 376
       else acc) prover_auto_levels []
  in
  fprintf str_formatter "start:@\n";
  List.iter (fun s -> fprintf str_formatter "c %s 1 1000@\n" s) provers_level1;
  fprintf str_formatter "t split_goal_wp start@\n";
  List.iter (fun s -> fprintf str_formatter "c %s 10 4000@\n" s) provers_level1;
  let code = flush_str_formatter () in
  let auto1 = {
      strategy_name = "Auto level 1";
      strategy_desc = "Automatic@ run@ of@ main@ provers";
      strategy_shortcut = "1";
      strategy_code = code }
  in
  (* Auto level 2 *)
  let provers_level2 =
    Hprover.fold
      (fun p (lev,b) acc ->
       if b && lev >= 1 && lev <= 2 then
377 378 379 380
         let name =
           p.Whyconf.prover_name ^ "," ^
             p.Whyconf.prover_version ^ "," ^ p.Whyconf.prover_altern
         in name :: acc
381 382 383 384 385 386 387 388 389
       else acc) prover_auto_levels []
  in
  fprintf str_formatter "start:@\n";
  List.iter (fun s -> fprintf str_formatter "c %s 1 1000@\n" s) provers_level2;
  fprintf str_formatter "t split_goal_wp start@\n";
  List.iter (fun s -> fprintf str_formatter "c %s 5 2000@\n" s) provers_level2;
  fprintf str_formatter "t introduce_premises afterintro@\n";
  fprintf str_formatter "afterintro:@\n";
  fprintf str_formatter "t inline_goal afterinline@\n";
390
  fprintf str_formatter "g trylongertime@\n";
391 392
  fprintf str_formatter "afterinline:@\n";
  fprintf str_formatter "t split_goal_wp start@\n";
393
  fprintf str_formatter "trylongertime:@\n";
394 395 396 397 398 399 400 401
  List.iter (fun s -> fprintf str_formatter "c %s 30 4000@\n" s) provers_level2;
  let code = flush_str_formatter () in
  let auto2 = {
      strategy_name = "Auto level 2";
      strategy_desc = "Automatic@ run@ of@ provers@ and@ most@ useful@ transformations";
      strategy_shortcut = "2";
      strategy_code = code }
  in
402 403 404
  add_strategy
    (add_strategy
       (add_strategy (add_strategy config inline) split) auto1) auto2
405

406 407 408 409 410 411 412
let detect_exec env main data acc exec_name =
  let s = ask_prover_version env exec_name data.version_switch in
  match s with
  | None -> acc
  | Some s ->
  let re = Str.regexp data.version_regexp in
  let ver =
413 414
    try
      ignore (Str.search_forward re s 0);
415
      Str.matched_group 1 s
416 417
    with Not_found ->
      begin
418
        Debug.dprintf debug "Warning: found prover %s but name/version not \
419
                       recognized by regexp `%s'@."
420
          data.prover_name data.version_regexp;
421 422 423 424
        Debug.dprintf debug "Answer was `%s'@." s;
        ""
      end
  in
425 426
  (* bad mean here not good, it's not the same thing than a version
     of a prover with known problems *)
427 428 429
  let bad = List.exists (check_version ver) data.versions_bad in
  if bad then (known_version env exec_name; acc)
  else
430 431 432
    (* check if this prover needs compile-time support *)
    let missing_compile_time_support =
      if data.compile_time_support then
433
        try
434
          let compile_time_ver =
435 436
            List.assoc data.prover_name Config.compile_time_support
          in
437
          if compile_time_ver <> ver then begin
438
            eprintf
439 440 441 442 443 444 445
              "Found prover %s version %s, but Why3 was compiled with support for version %s@."
            data.prover_name ver compile_time_ver;
            true
          end
          else
            false
        with Not_found ->
446
          eprintf
447 448 449 450 451 452 453 454
            "Found prover %s version %s, but Why3 wasn't compiled with support for it@."
            data.prover_name ver;
          true
      else false
    in
    if missing_compile_time_support then
      (known_version env exec_name; acc)
    else
455 456 457 458
    let good = List.exists (check_version ver) data.versions_ok in
    let old  = List.exists (check_version ver) data.versions_old in
    match data.prover_command with
    | None ->
459
      (* Empty prover *)
460
      if good || old then begin (* Known version with error *)
461 462 463
        known_version env exec_name;
        eprintf "Found prover %s version %s%s@."
          data.prover_name ver
464
          (Opt.get_def
465 466 467
             ". This version of the prover is known to have problems."
             data.message);
        acc
468
      end
469
      else (* it's not a known bad version *) acc
470

471
    | Some prover_command ->
472
    (* create the prover config *)
473
    let c = make_command exec_name prover_command in
474 475 476 477
    let c_steps = (match data.prover_command_steps with
      | None -> None
      | Some prover_command_steps ->
	Some (make_command exec_name prover_command_steps)) in
478 479 480 481 482 483
    let prover = {Wc.prover_name = data.prover_name;
                  prover_version      = ver;
                  prover_altern       = data.prover_altern} in
    let prover_config =
      {prover  = prover;
       command = c;
484
       command_steps = c_steps;
485 486 487 488 489 490 491
       driver  = Filename.concat (datadir main) data.prover_driver;
       editor  = data.prover_editor;
       in_place      = data.prover_in_place;
       interactive   = (match data.kind with ITP -> true | ATP -> false);
       extra_options = [];
       extra_drivers = [] } in

François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
492
    let priority = next_priority () in
493 494 495
    if good || old then begin
      eprintf "Found prover %s version %s%s@."
        data.prover_name ver
496 497 498 499 500 501 502 503
        (Opt.get_def
	   (if old then
	      " (old version, please consider upgrading)."
	    else
	      if data.prover_altern <> "" then
		" (alternative: " ^ data.prover_altern ^ ")"
	      else
		", OK.")
504 505
           data.message);
      known_version env exec_name;
506
      add_prover_shortcuts env prover;
François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
507
      add_id_prover_shortcut env data.prover_id prover priority;
508 509
      let level = data.use_at_auto_level in
      if level > 0 then record_prover_for_auto_mode prover level;
510 511
      add_prover_with_uniq_id prover_config acc
    end
François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
512 513
    else (unknown_version env exec_name data.prover_id prover_config priority;
          acc)
514 515 516 517 518 519

let detect_prover env main acc data =
  List.fold_left (detect_exec env main data) acc data.execs

(** add the prover unknown *)
let detect_unknown env detected =
François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
520
  Hstr.fold (fun _ pc acc ->
521 522
    match pc with
    | None -> acc
François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
523
    | Some (priority,prover_id,prover_config) ->
524
      let prover = prover_config.prover in
525
      Warning.emit "Warning: prover %s version %s is not known to be \
526
                     supported.@."
527
        prover.Wc.prover_name prover.prover_version;
528 529 530 531
      (* Pb: Even if it match the first prover section (normally
         highest priority) since it is unknown it has the lower
         priority for its id as shortcut. Perhaps we don't want
         that. *)
François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
532
      add_id_prover_shortcut env prover_id prover priority;
533 534
      add_prover_with_uniq_id prover_config acc)
    env.prover_unknown_version detected
535

536
let convert_shortcuts env =
François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
537
  Hstr.fold (fun s (_,p) acc ->
538
    check_prover_auto_level p; Mstr.add s p acc
539 540
  ) env.prover_shortcuts Mstr.empty

541 542
let run_auto_detection config =
  let main = get_main config in
543 544 545 546 547 548
  let l,env = read_auto_detection_data main in
  let detected = List.fold_left (detect_prover env main) Mprover.empty l in
  let length_detected = Mprover.cardinal detected in
  let detected = detect_unknown env detected in
  let length_unsupported_version =
    Mprover.cardinal detected - length_detected in
549 550 551
  eprintf
    "%d provers detected and %d provers detected with unsupported version@."
    length_detected length_unsupported_version;
552
  let shortcuts = convert_shortcuts env in
553
  let config = generate_auto_strategies config in
554 555 556 557
  let config = set_editors config (read_editors main) in
  let config = set_prover_shortcuts config shortcuts in
  let config = set_provers config detected in
  config
558 559

let list_prover_ids () =
560
  let config = default_config "" in
561
  let main = get_main config in
562
  let l,_ = read_auto_detection_data main in
563 564 565
  let s = List.fold_left (fun s p -> Sstr.add p.prover_id s) Sstr.empty l in
  Sstr.elements s

566
let get_suffix id alt =
567 568
  let ilen = String.length id in
  let alen = String.length alt in
569
  let rec aux i =
570 571
    if i = alen then "alt" else
    if i = ilen then String.sub alt i (alen-i) else
572
    if id.[i] = alt.[i] then aux (i+1) else
573 574
    String.sub alt i (alen-i)
  in
575 576 577 578 579 580
  aux 0


let get_altern id path =
  let alt = Filename.basename path in
  get_suffix id alt
581

582 583
let add_existing_shortcuts env shortcuts =
  let aux shortcut prover =
François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
584
    Hstr.replace env.prover_shortcuts shortcut (highest_priority,prover);
585
    env.possible_prover_shortcuts <-
François Bobot's avatar
François Bobot committed
586 587
      List.filter (fun (_,s) -> s = shortcut)
      env.possible_prover_shortcuts
588 589 590
  in
  Mstr.iter aux shortcuts

591 592
let add_prover_binary config id path =
  let main = get_main config in
593 594
  let l,env = read_auto_detection_data main in
  add_existing_shortcuts env (get_prover_shortcuts config);
595 596
  let l = List.filter (fun p -> p.prover_id = id) l in
  if l = [] then Loc.errorm "Unknown prover id: %s" id;
597 598 599 600 601
  let detected = List.fold_left
    (fun acc data -> detect_exec env main data acc path) Mprover.empty l in
  let detected = detect_unknown env detected in
  if Mprover.is_empty detected then
    Loc.errorm "File %s does not correspond to the prover id %s" path id;
602
  let provers = get_provers config in
603
  let fold _ p provers =
604
    (* find a prover altern not used *)
605 606 607
    (* Is a prover with this name and version already in config? *)
    let prover_id =
      if not (Mprover.mem p.prover provers) then p.prover else
608 609 610
        let alt = match p.prover.Wc.prover_altern, get_altern id path with
          | "", s -> s | s, "" -> s | s1, s2 -> s1 ^ " " ^ s2 in
        let prover_id = { p.prover with Wc.prover_altern = alt } in
611
        find_prover_altern provers prover_id in
612 613
    let p = {p with prover = prover_id} in
    add_prover_with_uniq_id p provers in
614
  let provers = Mprover.fold fold detected provers in
615
  let shortcuts = convert_shortcuts env in
616
  let config = set_provers config ~shortcuts provers in
617
  config